Activist investor to reap handsome return in Union Pacific – Norfolk Southern merger
One of the key beneficiaries of the proposed Union Pacific – Norfolk Southern merger is a largely under-the-radar activist investor who’s been shaking up underperforming transportation companies, one after another: C.H. Robinson, Forward Air, and Norfolk Southern.
Ancora Holdings, an activist investor known for its hands-on approach, has recently played a pivotal role in reshaping the trajectory of Norfolk Southern Corp. (NYSE: NSC). This involvement has been marked by a series of strategic maneuvers that culminated in significant changes within the railroad company’s management and its impending merger with Union Pacific, a move set to redefine the landscape of North American rail transport.
Ancora’s engagement with Norfolk Southern shareholders began in early 2024 when the investor mounted an aggressive campaign to enhance the company’s operational efficiency and financial performance. Discontented with the existing management and cost structure under CEO Alan Shaw, Ancora sought to push for better strategic outcomes. Despite initial resistance, Ancora’s persistence paid off, resulting in Shaw’s removal following an internal investigation into his inappropriate relationship with the company’s chief legal officer, Nabanita C. Nag. This series of events underscored Ancora’s influence, which was further solidified as they secured three seats on Norfolk Southern’s board of directors, providing a platform to advocate for deeper structural changes.
Amidst these boardroom shake-ups, Ancora maintained a keen focus on Norfolk Southern’s financials. The investor’s likely entry point can be traced back to when Norfolk Southern’s stock was trading predominantly between $220 and $260 per share earlier in 2024. This estimated cost basis would position Ancora well to reap substantial returns through strategic initiatives aimed at revitalizing the company’s performance and shareholder value.
The proposed merger with Union Pacific, valued at $85 billion, is set to create the first U.S. coast-to-coast freight operator, merging Union Pacific’s extensive western network with Norfolk Southern’s sprawling eastern connections. This merger has garnered unanimous support from the board, including the three members installed by Ancora, highlighting the investor’s endorsement of the strategic alignment and future prospects of the combined entity. With Union Pacific agreeing to purchase Norfolk Southern at $320 per share, Ancora stands to achieve a significant return on investment. Assuming an average cost basis in the range of $220 to $240 based on when Ancora built its position in the name, Ancora could potentially realize a return of 33% to 45%, depending on its precise cost basis.
Ancora’s intervention in Norfolk Southern comes at a crucial juncture for the transportation industry, which has been grappling with fluctuating freight volumes and rising operational costs. In particular, a soft trucking market has put persistent downward pressure on intermodal rates, and Norfolk Southern has the most exposure to intermodal of any Class I railroad. The broader sector has seen lackluster stock performance, reflecting a challenging market environment.
Perhaps most importantly, Wall Street has been waiting to see what the next chapter of the railroad industry, after the industry-wide adoption of versions of Hunter Harrison’s precision scheduled railroading, and the subsequent plunge operating ratios took into the 60s. After a decade of efficiency gains and deep cost cuts, what would come next? Within this context, Ancora’s Norfolk Southern trade highlights the role activist investors play in catalyzing change within companies, not only to unlock shareholder value but also to compel management to pursue operational excellence and strategic growth.
Ancora’s investment in Norfolk Southern is emblematic of a wider trend where activists seek to instigate corporate transformations, particularly in industries where traditional business models are under pressure. By intervening in Norfolk Southern and endorsing its merger with Union Pacific, Ancora aims to position the company favorably amidst the evolving economic landscape, ensuring robust returns for its investors while contributing to the consolidation and rationalization of North America’s rail network.
The post Activist investor to reap handsome return in Union Pacific – Norfolk Southern merger appeared first on FreightWaves.
